The NYT published an article this week on Sen. John McCain's overwhelming confidence in his own sense of propriety.
The story came under considerable fire, particularly for its use of anonymous sources (more than 2,400 comments were attached to the story).
A key allegation is that some anonymous individuals -- sourced as former aides to McCain, who is currently the presumptive Republican nominee for president -- thought he was having an affair with a younger lobbyist whose clients had business before a committee McCain chaired.
Both McCain and the lobbyist deny they had an affair.
In response, the NYT's editors and reporters took questions from readers. More than 4,000 were sent in.
NYT public editor Clark Hoyt weighs in:
more »