From the June 29 globeandmail.com story:
A police attempt to seize true-crime author Derek Finkle's files foundered yesterday when an Ontario judge blasted investigators for casting too wide a net.
"Fishing season is over; the subpoenas are quashed," said Mr. Justice David Watt of the Superior Court of Ontario.
Judge Watt said police and prosecutors in the Robert Baltovich murder case - which will be retried commencing in September - failed to furnish nearly enough specific information to support their request for two separate subpoenas.
He said authorities were also wrong to believe they could sit back and obtain "a breathtaking sweep" of material from Mr. Finkle, and then sift through it for anything that struck them as useful.
It is not enough to believe that there is "a mere possibility" that a seizure might produce relevant evidence, Judge Watt said. Instead, he said, police must show that they are "likely" to turn up material evidence.
The ruling ended a tumultuous year for Mr. Finkle, whose book, No Claim to Mercy, raised questions about Mr. Baltovich's conviction for the 1990 murder of his girlfriend, Elizabeth Bain.